Skip to content
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Polling
    • Scottish Parliament Polling
    • Westminster Polling
    • Independence Polling
  • Election Results
    • 2026 Scottish Parliament Election Results
      • Central Scotland and Lothians West Region Results 2026
      • Edinburgh and Lothians East Region Results 2026
      • Glasgow Region Results 2026
      • Highlands and Islands Region Results 2026
      • Mid Scotland and Fife Region Results 2026
      • North East Scotland Region Results 2026
      • South Scotland Region Results 2026
      • West Scotland Region Results 2026
    • 2024 UK General Election
      • GE24 Results: Aberdeen North to Falkirk
      • GE24 Results: Glasgow East to West Dunbartonshire
    • 2022 Local Elections
      • City Councils
        • Aberdeen City Council 2022
        • Dundee City Council 2022
        • City of Edinburgh Council 2022
        • Glasgow City Council 2022
      • Islands Councils
        • Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 2022
        • Orkney Islands Council 2022
        • Shetland Islands Council 2022
      • Rural Councils
        • Aberdeenshire Council 2022
        • Angus Council 2022
        • Argyll and Bute Council 2022
        • Dumfries and Galloway Council 2022
        • Highland Council 2022
        • Moray Council 2022
        • Perth and Kinross Council 2022
        • Scottish Borders Council 2022
      • Urban Councils (East)
        • Clackmannanshire Council 2022
        • East Lothian Council 2022
        • Falkirk Council 2022
        • Fife Council 2022
        • Midlothian Council 2022
        • Stirling Council 2022
        • West Lothian Council 2022
      • Urban Councils (West)
        • East Ayrshire Council 2022
        • East Dunbartonshire Council 2022
        • East Renfrewshire Council 2022
        • Inverclyde Council 2022
        • North Ayrshire Council 2022
        • North Lanarkshire Council 2022
        • Renfrewshire Council 2022
        • South Ayrshire Council 2022
        • South Lanarkshire Council 2022
        • West Dunbartonshire Council 2022
  • Explainers
    • Projections
    • A Brief Guide to Polling
    • Understanding Council By-Elections
    • By-Election Count Source Guide
    • Holyrood’s AMS Voting System Explained
    • The Local STV Voting System Explained
  • Party Leadership Elections
    • Scottish Green Party Leadership Election 2025
    • Scottish Conservative Leadership Election 2024
    • SNP Leadership Election 2023
    • Scottish Labour Leadership Election 2021
  • About BBS
    • About
    • Cookie Policy (UK)
    • Donations
    • Editorial Policy
  • New Municipalism Project
Donate

Proportional Representation

BBS EXCLUSIVE Poll Analysis: Survation 21st – 25th of June 2024
Posted in
  • Polling and Projections

BBS EXCLUSIVE Poll Analysis: Survation 21st – 25th of June 2024

With just one week left to go until the General Election, Labour are on track to win big at Westminster for the first time in nearly 15 years, whilst Reform UK eat into the Conservative vote. Meanwhile, Ballot Box Scotland positions on democratic reform are completely and utterly vindicated, with overwhelming public support.

by Ballot Box Scotland•June 26, 2024June 28, 2024
SP21 – Reforming AMS
Posted in
  • Proportional Representation
  • Scottish Parliament 2021

SP21 – Reforming AMS

Sure, Holyrood is unlikely to vote for my hyper-proportional, FPTP-free preferred voting system. But there are some solid, yet mild, reforms to AMS that could vastly improve it.

by Ballot Box Scotland•June 16, 2021September 11, 2021
SP21 – A Host of Hypotheticals
Posted in
  • Scottish Parliament 2021

SP21 – A Host of Hypotheticals

With analysis of the real election results out of the way, BBS now turns to one of my pet topics – hypothetical electoral reforms to improve proportionality!

by Ballot Box Scotland•June 3, 2021September 11, 2021
Throwing Stones in Crumbling Legislatures…
Posted in
  • Articles

Throwing Stones in Crumbling Legislatures…

Silly season came early to Scottish political Twitter, as charges of living in a “One Party State” started to appear. These mostly came from outwith Scotland, and the reaction from academics, journalists and politicians here has been absolute exasperation. Ballot Box Scotland was not immune to that feeling…

by Ballot Box Scotland•February 28, 2021February 28, 2021
Lockdown Fun With Voting Systems
Posted in
  • Proportional Representation

Lockdown Fun With Voting Systems

A look at a range of different tweaks to the Holyrood Voting System, because it’s Lockdown and everyone is bored!

by Ballot Box Scotland•May 4, 2020August 31, 2020
Long Read – Ballot Box Britain: GE 2019 Under PR
Posted in
  • Proportional Representation

Long Read – Ballot Box Britain: GE 2019 Under PR

Having worked out a simple PR model for the 2017 election just before GE19, it was easy to slot the numbers from this year in too. In an election notable for its tactical voting and heavily distorted result, I imagine a possible alternative to Westminster’s antiquated, unfair and fundamentally undemocratic voting system.

by Ballot Box Scotland•December 19, 2019August 31, 2020
Long Read – Ballot Box Britain: GE 2017 Under PR
Posted in
  • Proportional Representation

Long Read – Ballot Box Britain: GE 2017 Under PR

As something a bit different for a pre-Election long read, I take one last look back at the 2017 General Election. It’s a rare whole-UK moment for Ballot Box Scotland, as we take a trip through the alternate reality of having used Proportional Representation instead of First Past the Post the last time we elected the House of Commons.

by Ballot Box Scotland•December 7, 2019January 3, 2021
The Overhang Oddity
Posted in
  • Behind the Scenes

The Overhang Oddity

In my polling and projection posts, I’m finding myself quite regularly referring to a concept called … The Overhang OddityRead more

by Ballot Box Scotland•November 1, 2018August 31, 2020

Contact

Email: [email protected]

Support BBS

BlueSky Latest Posts

  • View post by Ballot Box Scotland on Bluesky

    Ballot Box Scotland @ballotbox.scot 2 days

    For many LGBT folk like me, and especially trans folk, Keir Starmer will be remembered in the same way as Margaret Thatcher: with deep contempt for having overseen a deeply hostile, queerphobic government, which rolled back human rights and set society back by at least a decade.

    Good riddance.
  • View post by Ballot Box Scotland on Bluesky

    Ballot Box Scotland @ballotbox.scot 2 days

    By-Election Result: Arbroath and Broughty Ferry

    The least exciting of the three by-elections that took place on Thursday, from a Scottish perspective it's the one closest to (but still not actually) a useful national barometer.
  • View post by Ballot Box Scotland on Bluesky

    Ballot Box Scotland @ballotbox.scot 4 days

    By-Election Result analysis: Aberdeen South

    A high profile move from Westminster to Holyrood leads to an absolutely huge loss for the SNP, as the Conservatives play a blinder of a tactical campaign.
  • View post by Ballot Box Scotland on Bluesky

    Ballot Box Scotland @ballotbox.scot 5 days

    As Conservative candidate and now MP, Douglas Lumsden, is also an MSP for the North East, he will have to resign from Holyrood within 49 days. That will bring in James Adams as his party replacement, as the only new Conservative MSP. This will also make Holyrood majority (65) new vs returning MSPs.
  • View post by Ballot Box Scotland on Bluesky

    Ballot Box Scotland @ballotbox.scot 5 days

    Arbroath and Broughty Ferry (Westminster) by-election result:

    SNP: 9802 (41.2%, +5.9)
    Conservative: 4524 (19%, +3.5)
    Reform UK: 4341 (18.3%, +9.6)
    Labour: 3651 (15.4%, -18)
    Lib Dem: 1452 (6.1%, +1)

    SNP HOLD
Last updated 10 minutes ago

Categories

  • Annual Reviews
  • Articles
  • Behind the Scenes
  • Boundary Reviews
  • Briefings
  • By-elections
  • EU Elections
  • Local Elections 2022
  • Polling and Projections
  • Proportional Representation
  • Scottish Parliament 2021
  • Scottish Parliament 2026
  • UK General Election 2019
  • UK General Election 2024
Copyright © 2026 Ballot Box Scotland.
Powered by WordPress and HybridMag.
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Polling
    • Scottish Parliament Polling
    • Westminster Polling
    • Independence Polling
  • Election Results
    • 2026 Scottish Parliament Election Results
      • Central Scotland and Lothians West Region Results 2026
      • Edinburgh and Lothians East Region Results 2026
      • Glasgow Region Results 2026
      • Highlands and Islands Region Results 2026
      • Mid Scotland and Fife Region Results 2026
      • North East Scotland Region Results 2026
      • South Scotland Region Results 2026
      • West Scotland Region Results 2026
    • 2024 UK General Election
      • GE24 Results: Aberdeen North to Falkirk
      • GE24 Results: Glasgow East to West Dunbartonshire
    • 2022 Local Elections
      • City Councils
        • Aberdeen City Council 2022
        • Dundee City Council 2022
        • City of Edinburgh Council 2022
        • Glasgow City Council 2022
      • Islands Councils
        • Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 2022
        • Orkney Islands Council 2022
        • Shetland Islands Council 2022
      • Rural Councils
        • Aberdeenshire Council 2022
        • Angus Council 2022
        • Argyll and Bute Council 2022
        • Dumfries and Galloway Council 2022
        • Highland Council 2022
        • Moray Council 2022
        • Perth and Kinross Council 2022
        • Scottish Borders Council 2022
      • Urban Councils (East)
        • Clackmannanshire Council 2022
        • East Lothian Council 2022
        • Falkirk Council 2022
        • Fife Council 2022
        • Midlothian Council 2022
        • Stirling Council 2022
        • West Lothian Council 2022
      • Urban Councils (West)
        • East Ayrshire Council 2022
        • East Dunbartonshire Council 2022
        • East Renfrewshire Council 2022
        • Inverclyde Council 2022
        • North Ayrshire Council 2022
        • North Lanarkshire Council 2022
        • Renfrewshire Council 2022
        • South Ayrshire Council 2022
        • South Lanarkshire Council 2022
        • West Dunbartonshire Council 2022
  • Explainers
    • Projections
    • A Brief Guide to Polling
    • Understanding Council By-Elections
    • By-Election Count Source Guide
    • Holyrood’s AMS Voting System Explained
    • The Local STV Voting System Explained
  • Party Leadership Elections
    • Scottish Green Party Leadership Election 2025
    • Scottish Conservative Leadership Election 2024
    • SNP Leadership Election 2023
    • Scottish Labour Leadership Election 2021
  • About BBS
    • About
    • Cookie Policy (UK)
    • Donations
    • Editorial Policy
  • New Municipalism Project
Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}